-->

Can Stocks Keep Defying Gravity?

Post a Comment
Shield

AN OXFORD CLUB PUBLICATION

Wealthy Retirement

View in browser

SPONSORED

Can You Actually Collect Big Income on Your Checking Account??

Piggy Bank
 

How Much Does Your Checking Account Pay You in Interest? Nothing?

If so, you need to see this. There's a way to get up to 119 times more income on your checking account than some banks pay on a savings account!

Stocks Defying Gravity? Don't Bet on It Lasting

Anthony Summers, Director of Trading, The Oxford Club

Anthony Summers

When you're keen on value investing, as I am, whether the stock market is overvalued matters a ton. And lately, I find myself wondering this more often than not.

It shouldn't be a hard question to answer. But what I've discovered is that few investors even want to know the answer.

Why? Because most seem to care little about intrinsic value and are instead more interested in perceived value. The thought seems to be "As long as there's a greater fool willing to buy my shares for more, it'll work out in the end."

That's great wishful thinking. But it's precisely the wrong way to approach investing. Both long-term investors and short-term traders ought to care about what they're buying - whether they intend to hold forever or flip for quick gains.

Successful investors understand that stocks' prices eventually follow their true value, although timing that convergence isn't always easy. As Warren Buffett famously put it, "Price is what you pay; value is what you get."

Not knowing (or caring) if an investment is underpriced or overpriced means making financial decisions in the dark.

But I assume, dear reader, that you are more thoughtful about your wealth than most - and neither afraid of nor apathetic to financial reality.

So... are stocks currently overvalued? Let's find the answer.

One of the simplest ways most folks try to answer this question is by turning to a so-called price multiple. For example, the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio - a stock's price divided by its earnings per share - is widely used as a gauge of whether stocks are cheap or expensive.

Over 150-plus years, the S&P 500's average P/E has been about 16. But right now, it's about 72% higher at 27.6.

Chart image
View larger image
 

So it looks like we've gotten our answer. Stocks are overvalued. Plain and simple.

But we're not quite done yet...

You see, while P/E is easy enough to understand, it's not without flaws. In fact, it could be seen as oversimplifying the picture.

An alternative is Nobel laureate Robert Shiller's cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings (CAPE) ratio, which factors in inflation and business cycles by using average inflation-adjusted earnings over 10 years.

Chart:
View larger image
 

The market's current CAPE ratio of 34.2 is double its long-term average of 17. So just like P/E ratio, the CAPE ratio is telling us valuations are higher than they have been historically.

But unlike P/E, the CAPE ratio says something more...

SPONSORED

Palm Beach Millionaire Is Giving Away His Top Income Secrets... FREE OF CHARGE.

Millionaire Sticker
 

CLICK HERE

Stocks aren't just overvalued. They're extremely overvalued.

In fact, the CAPE ratio has been this high only 4% of the time.

Chart: The Market's Historically High CAPE Ratio
View larger image
 

This should be alarming. But as I already noted, most retail investors and traders don't seem to care as much about valuations as they used to. (It's as if they can't imagine a reason NOT to buy stocks.)

Given that so few care, do these extreme valuations really matter in the end?

Absolutely, yes.

History has repeatedly proven that there's a true cost of overpaying for stocks: much, much lower long-term returns.

Even lower than those of risk-free assets.

Again, let's turn back to the CAPE ratio.

Whenever the market's CAPE ratio has topped 30, stocks have tended to underperform Treasurys over the subsequent 10-year period. (And, again, CAPE is currently near 35.)

Chart: High CAPE Precedes S&P Underperformance
View larger image
 

Yes, you read that right. We're talking about the highest-performing asset class in history underperforming the safest asset class in the world... by a wide margin.

Frankly, it's embarrassing - especially when you consider how value-blind investors are these days. But it's a lesson they'll have to learn one way or another.

The bottom line is this: Never get comfortable overpaying as a stock investor. It comes with a huge - and totally avoidable - cost to your wealth in the long run.

Be thoughtful about your wealth, and always consider value.

Or else.

Be excellent,

Anthony

Leave a Comment
The Oxford Club's Wealth, Wine and Wander Tour of Spain - Barcelona, Granada, Seville and Madrid, June 6-16, 2024 (plus special extension through June 21)

Get Marc's Top 5 Dividend Stocks (FREE PICKS)

The (Potential) $24 Trillion Market of the Future

See How to Access the Money Tool Metric Typically Reserved for World's Richest ($10M+ Net Worth)

My 4 Top Picks for 2024

SPONSORED

Alexander Green
 

He owns...

Amazon... 6,300%

Netflix... 20,400%

Apple... 94,000%.

Now he's unveiling the...

"Next Great American Super Stock."

More Here

Related Posts

There is no other posts in this category.

Post a Comment

Subscribe Our Newsletter